Keystone Politics - Pennsylvania's Political Community

Open Government: April 2009 Archives

Attorney Paul Wright of Seattle-based Prison Legal News was stunned when he filed a right-to-know request with the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections and was told the department didn't have the information he sought.

Wright wanted records on lawsuit settlements. The department responded that it isn't required to create records.

"I call it the 'Right to Know Nothing Law,' " Wright said of Pennsylvania's open records statute.

Pennsylvania's updated law was supposed to start an era of transparency Jan. 1, but it has raised troubling issues along the way.

On the upside, public interest is heightened, said Terry Mutchler, director of the Pennsylvania Office of Open Records, who is swamped with inquiries and appeals from denials. Mutchler said citizens, not journalists, have led the way, filing more than 90 percent of the nearly 300 pending appeals.

The Rendell administration appears to be going out of its way to block public access to government documents. At least that is the impression left on the state's new open-records czar.

Terry Mutchler, executive director of Pennsylvania's Office of Public Records, has written to Gov. Rendell questioning whether top administration officials share the view that government should be open and transparent.

In the three-page letter, obtained by The Inquirer, Mutchler revealed a list of her concerns over how the administration has dealt with her and her staff - as well as individual records requests - since she was tapped to lead the open-records office in June.

According to her letter, the situation has gotten so bad that lawyers in Rendell's office have put representatives of every state agency on notice not to even take her calls. Everything has to be in writing, the lawyers insist.

House GOP looks at Ethics Reform

House Republicans on Monday proposed a package of ethical reforms for state government including limits on staff campaigning and use of nonprofit organizations by public officials -- activities that figured into high-profile criminal prosecutions of Democrats in the Legislature.

"The status-quo mindset, the corruption and the general lack of good judgment must end," said House Minority Leader Sam Smith of Punxsutawney. "Everything government does is suspect anymore, so cleaning up the mess must be our first step."

Some of the GOP proposals have merit but some are redundant, said Brett Marcy, a spokesman for House Majority Leader Todd Eachus, D-Wilkes-Barre. He said the House adopted a rule in 2007 preventing lawmakers' involvement in nonprofits.

"We welcome Republicans to the fold of reform," Marcy said. "We've been a backer of reform efforts over the past two years. Certainly, accountability and transparency are something we should all strive for."


blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you